Much has been said already about John C Wright (
johncwright) and his wife L. Jagi Lamplighter (
arhyalon) and their contributions to the most recent round of racefail. (If you don't know what that is, you can start
with this post and then pick up the various gory details at
karnythia and
kate_nepveu's livejournals.) Wright made himself lj-famous on his own with
an incredibly strange post about "homosex", the decline of western civilization, and gay characters on the SyFy channel, which is something of a train wreck of fail and has provoked a ton of lefty responses in the comments thread. (
anarchomo describes the post as "a moral 2 girls 1 cup" -- once you've read it and processed the trauma, you feel compelled to show it to other people and film
their reactions.)
I don't have anything to add to the particulars of these discussions. But I do want to rant about something of which Wright is a particularly egregious example: zealous conservative converts to Roman Catholicism.
Apparently at around age 42, Wright had a sequence of mystical experiences
which he recounts in this post and which culminated in his conversion to Christianity. Later, in 2008, he converted to Catholicism. You should really read that post and the comment threads, they're worth it.
I have remarks on two topics here.
The first is the conversion experience itself. If you sample around Wright's journal, you will find that he adopts a posture of absolute moral certainty with the respect to the correctness of the doctrines of the Catholic Church. He has educated himself deeply enough to quote from a wide variety of classical church scholars on canon law and on Natural Law theory. All other moral stances are "antinomian" and thoroughly irrational. Indeed, he is quoted as saying that "If the Vulcans had a church, they would be Catholics."
And yet -- was his conversion to Christianity effected through the cold, implacable working of Logic? No. He had to be visited four times, by each member of the Trinity and by the Virgin Mary herself, and receive personal and secret revelation, before he was convinced.
I've never been visited individually by the persons of the Catholic Godhead (nor by Mary). I'm not sure what my reaction would be if I were. I will admit the strong possibility that if I had been, I would still be a Catholic. Certainly I might be a zealous Catholic. That might be the logical response to direct and personal revelation. But it's exactly the opposite of an alleged
universal appeal to rationality! It irritates me that in the face of such a direct contradiction present in his own personal history, he proceeds to adopt a supercilious tone with respect to the "obvious" rational correctness of Catholicism.
My other observation about this conversion story is that I've never before met someone who managed to condescend to the Virgin Mary. But Wright does it. And after he received a personal visitation from her! That takes a lot of gumption.
The second topic is Wright's reaction to his conversion experience. I am sick and tired of conservatives who convert to Catholicism only to find that, lo and behold, the Catholic Church reinforces their every preconceived stance on moral issues. And not just homosexuality and abortion, but patriotism, the Iraq war, and gun rights as well. They converted and changed their opinions about nothing but the existence of God. Usually they will sneeringly refer to other Catholics -- especially liberal Catholics -- as "cafeteria Catholics".
I'm sorry, but the Catholic Church for all its flaws is definitely more problematic than
that. Pope John Paul II declared the Iraq War to be morally unjustified according to Catholic just war doctrine. Not that I hold JP2 to be the final moral arbiter of any question, but the sheer hypocrisy of people who will with one breath defend the (extremely contentious even within the Church of the time)
Humanae Vitae as dogma, and yet will blithely dismiss JP2 out of hand when he has things to say about their pet war (and will even go so far as to call anti-war protestors treasonous, apparently putting Caesar above God) -- it just galls me. Similarly, I'd love to see John C Wright sit down with Jesus of Nazareth and explain how you're only "free" if you are free to possess and use firearms in your own defense. And of course as far as my limited searching around his LJ could turn up, Wright nowhere addresses
Caritas in Veritate, but it will take a lot of twisting and turning to fit it into his libertarian politics. Similarly I couldn't find Wright taking a position on the death penalty, but it wouldn't surprise me if he were "pro-". I certainly have acquaintances of a similar political and religious persuasion who are. Who are the cafeteria Catholics here?
It really depresses me that the people who receive personal revelations from God are such awful human beings. It certainly makes their testimony much less powerful. I could convert back to Catholicism and become ... like John C Wright! Or I could remain a humanist atheist and be able to live with myself. The choice is not hard.
I'd like to close on a happier note. L. Jagi Lamplighter, just released a new hardcover fantasy, the first in a series entitled
Prospero's Daughter. After her antics at Worldcon, it's unlikely that people on my friends list are going to run right out and buy a copy.
Instead of a simple boycott, though I'd like to encourage you all to take some positive action; in this case, you can do so by buying a copy of
Prospero's Daughter by Trinidadian writer
Elizabeth Nunez. You can read more about it by following those links, but here are some positive reviews that make me look forward to the read:
"Nunez critiques colonialist assumptions about race and class in this ambitious reworking of The Tempest, set in her native Trinidad in the early 1960s. . . . [It has] strong themes and dramatic ironies. Readers will find her love story—which has a refreshingly happy ending—very sensitively told." —Publishers Weekly
Exquisite retelling of The Tempest….Nunez’s masterful story plays out against the backdrop of Trinidadian hopes for independence, achieved the following year. Simply wonderful. —Kirkus Starred review